OeS 6 software is intended for modeling and calculation of radial and multiply closed power networks, under operating and short-circuit conditions. The program’s computational capabilities allow for the analysis of the operation of HV, MV and LV networks within one model. The program is also equipped with modules supporting the selection of protection settings and determining the load capacity of cables depending on the installation conditions. OeS has always been created as an engineering tool – it is characterized by transparency and simplicity of use, while maintaining a full range of computational functionalities for the implementation of analytical and design tasks.

Individual OeS software modules allow you to perform power flow and short-circuit calculations, which are an indispensable element of every project or connection expertise. Available functionalities enable, among others: proper selection of devices with regard to operation in operating and short-circuit conditions, solving problems related to reactive power compensation or assessment of the operation of the neutral point. They also support planning the expansion of the existing network and help in making connection decisions. In the OeS software, you can quickly perform calculations for any network configuration, which opens up great opportunities for users to create multi-variant analyses.

Functionalities related to modeling and analysis of network security operation have also been developed for many years. The user can analyze the sensitivity and selectivity of protections, determine their response times, and assess the risk of shock. Additionally, OeS can be equipped with the PROKAB module, which allows for the creation and calculation of the longitudinal and transverse profiles of the cable and the determination of substitute parameters for overhead lines. Another additional element is the GRAFIK module, which allows for the modeling of consumers taking into account the variability of the load over time (operator’s tariff or measurement data) and the modeling of prosumers taking into account the variability of their generation. The possibility of using the ENTSO-E database (climate years) has been implemented here, taking into account the weather forecast in the calculations or entering measurement data. Computational functionalities allow for the analysis of time histories of power and branch currents, voltages in network nodes, losses and other network parameters.

Short circuits

Calculations in disturbance states include:

  • calculations of symmetrical short-circuit current parameters,
  • calculation of the parameters of the minimum symmetrical short-circuit current,
  • calculations of symmetrical short-circuit current flow,
  • calculations of asymmetric short-circuit current parameters,
  • calculations of asymmetrical short-circuit current flow.

The methodology for calculating short-circuit currents is based on the standard PN-EN 60909-0 – for symmetrical short-circuits and PN-EN 60909-3 – for asymmetrical short-circuits.

Calculations of short-circuit currents are made based on an appropriately constructed equivalent network diagram. In this diagram, there is a substitute voltage source at the fault site and network elements presented in the form of impedance doubles. The substitute voltage source is the only active source in the diagram and replaces all real sources. The sources of short-circuit current include: the supply network, generators, synchronous and asynchronous motors and equivalents of substitute networks.

Calculations of symmetrical short-circuit current parameters

In the calculation of the symmetrical short-circuit current parameters, a short-circuit is assumed in each analyzed node and the characteristic parameters of the short-circuit current flowing to that node are determined.

The analysis of exceedances consists in checking the elements according to the given strength:

  • surge – applies to busbars and connectors, exceeding the limit parameters is checked, i.e. peak current ipor surge current ip
  • switching – applies to switches, the maximum breaking current Icuis checked for exceeding the symmetrical short-circuit breaking current of 20 ms calculated for a given element,
  • thermal – applies to power lines, busbars and connectors, exceeding the thermal short-circuit current Ithr is checked.

Additionally, when analyzing exceedances for power lines, the temperature increase of the current path during a short circuit is also determined.

All calculated parameters have been grouped in the result window and are visible in tabs, as shown below:

  • Fault current parameters tab:
    • nominal voltage Un(kV) – nominal voltage (voltage level) of the network in which a given node is located,
    • initial short-circuit current Ik” (kA) – modulus of the resultant complex value of the short-circuit current, calculated for all sources, Ik” = | ΣIki|
    • total initial short-circuit current according to the share of sources ΣIk” (kA) – the sum of the modules of the complex values of individual short-circuit currents flowing to the short-circuit location from each source, ΣIk ” = Σ|Iki|,
    • short-circuit power Sk” (MVA),
    • peak short-circuit current ipA(kA) – the κ coefficient determined for the ratio R/X of the resultant impedance of the network affected by the short circuit is assumed, method in accordance with the standard,
    • peak short-circuit current ipB(kA) – the value of the κ coefficient is assumed increased by 15% compared to that calculated in method A, the method recommended according to the standards for closed networks; in which high heterogeneity causes the R/X relations in individual branches of the replacement scheme to be different,
    • peak short-circuit current ipC(kA) – is the sum of the components calculated for each short-circuit current source separately, based on a different coefficient κ – depending on the R/X ratio of a particular branch of the equivalent circuit; the most accurate method, but non-normative,
    • short-circuit breaking current for 20 ms Ib20(kA) – symmetrical,
    • short-circuit breaking current for 50 ms Ib50(kA) – symmetrical,
    • short-circuit breaking current for 100 ms Ib100(kA) – symmetrical,
    • short-circuit breaking current for 250 ms Ib250(kA) – symmetrical,
    • aperiodic component of the short-circuit current for a time of 20 ms iDC20(kA) – aperiodic component current,
    • aperiodic component of the short-circuit current for a time of 50 ms iDC50(kA) ) – aperiodic component current,
    • aperiodic component of the short-circuit current for 100 ms iDC100(kA) ) – aperiodic component current,
    • aperiodic component of the short-circuit current for a time of 250 ms iDC250(kA) ) – aperiodic component current,
    • asymmetrical short-circuit breaking current for 20 ms Ibasym20(kA) – Ib supplemented by iDC,
    • asymmetrical short-circuit breaking current for 50 ms Ibasym50(kA) – Ib supplemented by iDC,
    • asymmetrical short-circuit breaking current for 100 ms Ibasym100(kA) – Ib supplemented by iDC,
    • asymmetrical short-circuit breaking current for 250 ms Ibasym250(kA) – Ib supplemented by iDC,
    • steady-state short-circuit current Ik(kA),
    • thermal equivalent of short-circuit current of specified time – value determined on the basis of the coefficients m and n Ith (t s)(kA),
    • thermal equivalent of short-circuit current of specified time converted to 1 s Ithr(1s)(kA),
    • thermal equivalent of short-circuit current of specified time converted to 3 s Ithr(3s)(kA),
  • Potential exceedances tab:
      • busbar surge current or switch peak current ipr(kA) – basis for determining the exceedance of the surge strength,
      • impact load degree ip/i pr(%),
      • exceeding (impact strength) – signals exceedance when (ip/ipr)> > 100%,
      • maximum breaking current of the switch Icu(kA) – basis for determining the switching strength,
      • connector load degree Ib/Icu(%),
      • exceeding (connective strength) – signals exceedance when (Ib/Icu)> > 100%,
      • thermal short-circuit current 1 s Ithr(kA) for the switch and busbar, and for the power line, for which this parameter is determined on the basis of the permissible one-second short-circuit current density Ithr (kA),
      • degree of heat load Ithr(t)/Ithr(%),
      • exceedance (thermal strength) – indicates an exceedance when (Ithr(t)/Ithr)> > 100%,
      • temperature rise during a short circuit ΔT (K) – only for power lines.
  • Exceedances tab – based on short-circuit current flow calculations

 

Calculation of minimum parameters of symmetrical short-circuit current.

Determination of the minimum parameters of symmetrical short-circuit current is performed analogously to the calculation of the parameters of symmetrical short-circuit current. The important differences are:

  • adopt the minimum values of the voltage coefficient “c” – respectively, for the nominal voltage of the network,
  • ignoring the effect of impedance correction factors of transformers and synchronous generators,
  • ignoring the impact of prosumer sources (wind farms, photovoltaics and others), synchronous and asynchronous motors on the value of short-circuit current,
  • taking into account the increase in resistance of the current paths resulting from the heating of the wires

All calculated parameters, presented in the resulting window, are shown below:

  • nominal voltage Un(kV) – nominal voltage (voltage level) of the network in which the node is located,
  • the minimum initial short-circuit current Ik 3fmin(kA) – the modulus of the resultant value of the combined short-circuit current, calculated for all sources, Ik” = |ΣIki|,
  • summary min. initial short-circuit current according to the shares of the sources ΣIkmin(kA) – the sum of the modules of the combined values of the individual short-circuit currents, flowing to the site of the short circuit from each source, ΣIk” = Σ|Iki|,
  • Minimum two-phase initial short-circuit current Ik2fmin(kA),
  • minimum short-circuit power Skmin(MVA),
  • minimum steady-state short-circuit current Ikmin(kA),
  • minimum two-phase initial fault current Ik2f min G(kA) – calculated according to mining standard PN-G-42042 Ik2f min G (kA).

 

Calculation of symmetrical short-circuit current flow

The calculation of the symmetrical short-circuit current flow allows the analysis of the branch components of the short-circuit current and nodal voltages, assuming a short circuit at the selected node of the network.

All calculated parameters have been grouped in the resulting window and can be seen in tabs, as shown below:

  • Node Results tab:
    • nominal network voltage Un(kV),
    • the real part of the voltage at a given node of the network during a short circuit Re{U} (kV),
    • the imaginary part of the voltage at a given node of the network at the time of the short circuit Im{U} (kV),
    • Voltage modulus at a given network node during a short-circuit U (kV),
  • Branch Results tab:
    • nominal branch voltage Un(kV),
    • the real part of the short-circuit current, flowing in a given branch of the network during the short circuit Re{Ik“} (kA),
    • imaginary part of the short-circuit current, flowing in a given branch of the network during the duration of a short circuit Im{Ik“} (kA),
    • the modulus of the short-circuit current, flowing in a given branch during a short circuit Ik” (kA).

 

Calculation of parameters of asymmetrical short-circuit current

In the calculation of asymmetrical short-circuit current, a transformer is modeled depending on the connection arrangement of its windings. The modeled connection arrangements include:

  • for double-winding transformers:
    • grounded star – delta, YnD,
    • grounded star – star, YnY,
    • star grounded – star grounded, YnYn,
    • star – star, YY,
    • star – delta, YD,
    • zigzag grounded – star grounded, ZnYn,
    • autotransformer: star grounded – delta, YnD.
  • for three-winding transformers:
    • star grounded – star grounded – delta, YnYnD,
    • star grounded – star – delta, YnYD,
    • grounded-star – delta – delta, YnDD.

The connection arrangements, not described above, provide a break for the zero component in asymmetrical calculations. In the calculation of asymmetrical fault current, synchronous and asynchronous motors are not considered as sources of fault current.

 

The calculation of the parameters of unsymmetrical short-circuit current includes many variants of the analyzed disturbance, they include:

  • single-phase short circuit,
  • single-phase short circuit with neutral conductor (only for low-voltage network),
  • two-phase short circuit,
  • two-phase short circuit with earth,
  • three-phase short circuit

All calculated parameters have been grouped in the resulting window and can be seen in tabs – according to the type of interference analyzed. These parameters include:

  • nominal voltage Un(kV) – the nominal voltage of the network in which the node is located,
  • short-circuit current of the zero component I0(kA),
  • short-circuit current of the compliant component I1(kA),
  • short-circuit current of the opposite component I2(kA),
  • L1 phase short-circuit current IL1(kA),
  • L2 phase short-circuit current IL2(kA),
  • L3 phase short-circuit current IL3(kA),
  • real part of the short-circuit loop impedance Re{Z} (Ω),
  • imaginary part of the short-circuit loop impedance Im{Z} (Ω),
  • modulus of short-circuit loop impedance Z (Ω).

Parameters for a single-phase short circuit with the neutral conductor are determined only for low-voltage networks. However, for a two-phase short circuit with earth, the impedance of the short circuit loop is not determined.

 

Calculations of unbalanced short-circuit current distribution

Calculations of asymmetrical short-circuit current flow are performed analogously to calculations of symmetrical short-circuit current flow.

Full calculation results are available in the result window. All calculated parameters have been grouped there (due to the type of result and the analyzed short circuit) and are visible in tabs, as shown below:

  • node results:
    • nominal network voltage Un(kV),
    • zero sequence voltage U0(kV),
    • positive sequence voltage U1(kV),
    • negative sequence voltage U2(kV),
    • L1 phase voltage UL1(kV),
    • L2 phase voltage UL2(kV),
    • L3 phase voltage UL3(kV),
  • branch results:
    • nominal voltage of the branch Un(kV),
    • zero sequence short-circuit current I0(kA),
    • positive sequence short-circuit current I1(kA),
    • negative sequence short-circuit current I2(kA),
    • L1 phase short-circuit current IL1(kA),
    • L2 phase short-circuit current IL2(kA),
    • L3 phase short-circuit current IL3(kA),

 

Analysis of exceedances

The OeS 6 program enables variant analysis of the operation of the modeled network in terms of exceeding the limit parameter values and determining the minimum and maximum values of parameters characterizing the network. For this purpose, the network operation variants intended for such analysis should be previously defined.

Full analysis results are available in the result window. It presents the minimum and maximum values of characteristic parameters and exceedances of limit parameters along with the configuration variant for which they occurred. All calculated parameters are grouped in the result window (depending on the type of result and the selected type of calculation) and are visible in tabs as shown below:

      • Flow Calculations tab:
        • Node Results tab:
          • minimum voltage |U|min(kV),
          • variant – name of the variant in which the minimum voltage in the node was found,
          • maximum voltage |U|max(kV),
          • variant – name of the variant in which the maximum voltage in the node was found,
        • Branch Results tab:
          • minimum current |I|min(A),
          • variant – name of the variant in which the minimum current in the branch was found,
          • maximum current |I|max(A),
          • variant – name of the variant in which the maximum current in the branch was found,
          • minimum calculated load level Id%min(%) – only for transformers and power lines for which the long-term permissible current has been defined,
          • variant – name of the variant in which the minimum calculated load level was found,
          • exceeding – signals an exceedance when Id%min> 100%,
          • maximum calculated load level Id%max(%) – only for transformers and power lines for which long-term permissible current has been defined,
          • variant – name of the variant in which the maximum calculated load level was found,
          • exceeding – signals an exceedance when Id%max> 100%,
      • Fault current parameters tab:
        • Initial short-circuit current tab:
          • nominal voltage Un(kV),
          • minimum initial short-circuit current |I k”|min(kA),
          • variant – name of the variant in which the minimum value of the initial short-circuit current was found,
          • maximum initial short-circuit current |I k”|max(kA),
          • variant – name of the variant in which the maximum value of the initial short-circuit current was found,
        • Short circuit power tab:
          • nominal voltage Un(kV),
          • minimum short-circuit power |Sk”|min(MVA),
          • variant – name of the variant in which the minimum value of short-circuit current or power was found,
          • maximum short-circuit power |Sk”|max(MVA),
          • variant – name of the variant in which the maximum value of short-circuit current or power was found,
        • Surge current tab:
          • nominal voltage Un(kV),
          • minimum surge current |ipC|min(kA),
          • variant – name of the variant in which the minimum value of the surge current was found,
          • maximum surge current |ipC|max(kA),
          • variant – name of the variant in which the maximum value of the surge current was found,
        • Thermal short-circuit current tab for a short-circuit duration of 0.1 s:
          • nominal voltage Un(kV),
          • minimum thermal short-circuit current for a short-circuit time of 0.1 s Ith(t)min(kA),
          • variant – name of the variant in which the minimum value of thermal short-circuit current was found for a short-circuit duration of 0.1 s,
          • maximum thermal short-circuit current for a short-circuit time of 0.1 s Ith(t)max(kA),
          • variant – name of the variant in which the maximum value of thermal short-circuit current was found for a short-circuit time of 0.1 s,
        • Short-circuit breaking current tab for a short-circuit duration of 250 ms:
          • nominal voltage Un(kV),
          • minimum symmetrical breaking current for a short-circuit time of 250 ms Ib250min(kA),
          • variant – name of the variant in which the minimum value of the symmetrical breaking current was found for a short-circuit time of 250 ms,
          • maximum symmetrical breaking current for a short-circuit time of 250 ms Ib250max(kA),
          • variant – name of the variant in which the maximum value of the symmetrical breaking current was found for a short-circuit time of 250 ms.